Did the Buffalo Bills actually WIN the controversial NFL Draft trade that allowed the Kansas City Chiefs to select Xavier Worthy? Keon Coleman's breakout season under Joe Brady is changing the conversation around Brandon Beane's decision. On Bills HIT, we revisit one of Buffalo's most debated draft decisions and ask whether the long-term results are starting to favor the Bills. Buffalo traded back with Kansas City in the 2024 NFL Draft, allowing the Chiefs to select Xavier Worthy while the Bills eventually landed Keon Coleman and added draft capital that helped them acquire defensive tackle DeWayne Carter. At the time, many Bills fans questioned whether Brandon Beane had made a costly mistake by helping an AFC rival land an explosive receiver. But the conversation looks different in 2026. Coleman has emerged as one of Buffalo's most important offensive weapons while DJ Moore has dealt with injuries. According to the statistics discussed in the episode, Coleman ranks 13th among NFL wide receivers in total EPA and has been one of the league's most productive receivers on a per-target basis. Meanwhile, Xavier Worthy has struggled to find consistent production this season, raising new questions about how the two receivers compare. DeWayne Carter's development also adds another dimension to the trade evaluation, particularly as Buffalo looks for improvements along its defensive front. But there's another side to this debate. Worthy delivered a 100-yard receiving performance in the AFC Championship Game, giving Kansas City meaningful postseason production. Does that outweigh Coleman's recent emergence? And if Coleman becomes a reliable second receiving option alongside DJ Moore and eventually earns another contract with Buffalo, would that make the trade a success even without a Super Bowl victory? We also discuss Joe Brady's influence on Coleman's development and whether Brandon Beane deserves more credit for the decision. Bills Mafia, it's time to revisit the debate. Who won the Keon Coleman–Xavier Worthy trade? #BuffaloBills #BillsMafia #KeonColeman Photo Credit: Junfu Han Support Us By Supporting Our Sponsors! KALSHI For a limited time, Download the Kalshi app and use code [LOCKEDON] to get up to $500 in bonus credits when you trade $25.
Did the Buffalo Bills actually WIN the controversial NFL Draft trade that allowed the Kansas City Chiefs to select Xavier Worthy? Keon Coleman's breakout season under Joe Brady is changing the conversation around Brandon Beane's decision.
On Bills HIT, we revisit one of Buffalo's most debated draft decisions and ask whether the long-term results are starting to favor the Bills.
Buffalo traded back with Kansas City in the 2024 NFL Draft, allowing the Chiefs to select Xavier Worthy while the Bills eventually landed Keon Coleman and added draft capital that helped them acquire defensive tackle DeWayne Carter.
At the time, many Bills fans questioned whether Brandon Beane had made a costly mistake by helping an AFC rival land an explosive receiver.
But the conversation looks different in 2026.
Coleman has emerged as one of Buffalo's most important offensive weapons while DJ Moore has dealt with injuries.
According to the statistics discussed in the episode, Coleman ranks 13th among NFL wide receivers in total EPA and has been one of the league's most productive receivers on a per-target basis.
Meanwhile, Xavier Worthy has struggled to find consistent production this season, raising new questions about how the two receivers compare.
DeWayne Carter's development also adds another dimension to the trade evaluation, particularly as Buffalo looks for improvements along its defensive front.
But there's another side to this debate.
Worthy delivered a 100-yard receiving performance in the AFC Championship Game, giving Kansas City meaningful postseason production.
Does that outweigh Coleman's recent emergence?
And if Coleman becomes a reliable second receiving option alongside DJ Moore and eventually earns another contract with Buffalo, would that make the trade a success even without a Super Bowl victory?
We also discuss Joe Brady's influence on Coleman's development and whether Brandon Beane deserves more credit for the decision.
Bills Mafia, it's time to revisit the debate.
Who won the Keon Coleman–Xavier Worthy trade?
#BuffaloBills #BillsMafia #KeonColeman
Photo Credit: Junfu Han
Support Us By Supporting Our Sponsors!
KALSHI
For a limited time, Download the Kalshi app and use code [LOCKEDON] to get up to $500 in bonus credits when you trade $25.